Another Response To Missing The Boat

Brother Junius adds his 2 cents to How Freemasonry is Missing the Boat.

This essay makes a good point. The “trick.” if I may so term it, is to lead the nation in a broad and benevolent sense without, in fact, drifting into distinct political and social philosophies – socialism, capitalism, big government, small government, more taxes, less taxes and so on and so forth. This is not an easy thing to do, although it may be easy to say or suggest.

Secondly, I think something else was or is involved, and it is rather difficult to put into words. From about the late ‘sixties until, perhaps, the first five years of this century, we have dealt with a generation of men who were not, by-and-large, “joiners,” in the sense of entering clubs, church congregations, service groups and, of course, Freemasonry. It seemed as if that kind of interest had largely evaporated into thin air, so to speak.

Even as late as 1990 there was talk of large-scale “coccooning,” in our society, where people wrapped themselves in the private world of their increasingly spacious and luxurious homes, communicating externally by the Internet and importing entertainment, news and even conversations with others using all the new communications technology even then evolving. People ” went to meetings,” without ever leaving the house; they “travelled” all over the world and within the nation by high definition, 50″ flat screen televisions; they “went shopping and to the bank,” on the Internet and at places such as E-Bay; they “went to the movies,” with Netflix and movie channels – and so on and so forth. Many even “went to work” all or most of the time in the home-based study, or operated businesses out of the basement or the garage!

There is evidence of this in the decline of all kinds of groups other than Masons, such as the Loyal Order of Moose, the Oddfellows, Lions, Optimists and so on.

At the same time, the minority who were joiners were attracted to organizations, which, by their own nature, were not compatible with or were even hostile to Freemasonry.

I also approve of the mention of multiple causation: it was not only the economic and social equality of women, but partly; not only the rise of all kinds of exciting, absorbing and available alternate forms of free-time entertainment, but partly; not only increased physical mobility over distance, and more frequent migration from one area or town or city to another, but partly; not only a combination of religious fundamentalism and active evangelism on the one hand and the decline of so-called mainstream, older denominations on the other, but partly; not only fewer and fewer male children per married couple, but partly.

I do agree that trying to market Freemasonry as if it was some sort of commercial product, such as soap, a vacume cleaner, or even a car, was and is a mistake.

In a similar vein, the centralized organization of large and very public Masonic charities may well have done a great deal of good socially, and while not necessarily invalid in itself, had little or no effect on long-term, steady increase in membership.

There is some indication that the world may be about to turn yet again. Here, in Ontario, our Grand Lodge appears at least to have stopped the bleeding – last year, and the year before, we had a modest net increase ( 2% or so) in total membership for the first time in decades.  Partly, this might be attributed to an active Friend to Friend program the lodges have been encouraged to use at the lodge level, involving personal friends of Masons, and often their wives or fiancees, dining together and having a presentation in the Lodge rooms about Freemasonry – a bit of its history, some of its ideals, and information about costs, time and so on.

However, having said that, I think something else is going on. One way to put it would be the old idea that success feeds on success, and one happy, inspired new member is likely to produce more, given a little time. Doing good ritual is an example. We have found that lodges consistently doing good ritual are lodges that the younger brethren are proud of, and are something they do not hesitate to talk about with their non-Masonic friends or colleagues at work.  Younger members also appreciate the following:

  1. Social events involving the ladies, however modestly run: BBQ, wine and cheese reception, restaurant dinner, dinner-dance evening, and so on.
  2. Immediate opportunities to lead in the life of the lodge – Education, running the web site, acting as social leader, auditor, long range planning chairman, and so on
  3. Getting started into the Chairs asap.

One other point: it is becoming increasingly evident to me at least that there are a lot of younger adult men out there who are looking for some group or organization that has a philosophic or even a spiritual dimension, but without a formal, restrictive theological system. If this be so, and I believe it is, then Freemasonry is poised to provide what is desired. In essence, “we have an appfor that.”

Brother Junius

Posted in The Bee Hive and tagged , , .

Fred is a Past Master of Plymouth Lodge, Plymouth Massachusetts, and Past Master of Paul Revere Lodge, Brockton, Massachusetts. Presently, he is a member of Pride of Mt. Pisgah No. 135, Prince Hall Texas, where is he is also a Prince Hall Knight Templar . Fred is a Fellow of the Phylaxis Society and Executive Director of the Phoenix Masonry website and museum.


  1. As a young man about to be initiated into Freemasonry (27, and in June) I can definatly vouch for what Junius is saying. I was drawn to Freemasonry as I want to be part of an organization that holds everyones theological idiologies equally, and in part an organization that isn’t strictly charitable, but a place that challenges me to further mold myself into someone better, and in a way that I feel fits my ideologies. I love the concept of meeting on the level and parting on the square. I have never done any research on the ritual but I know from a friend who was a past grand master of the grand lodge of saskatchewan that if the ritual is presented well you get alot more out of meetings, and are more likely to stay. Looking forward to talking to all you brethren after I knock at the gate in June!

  2. Hello Brothers,

    Adding to the above discussion, I believe that we must also consider the importance of sleceting the right candidate for initiation. How effectively are we ensuring that the proposed member for initiation is of his “own free will and accord”?

    If the members are not truly “ready” for Freemasonry, Rituals, no matter how well they are presented, will impart no message. In a rush to increase membership, the lodges might miss on the fundamental purpose of making “Good Men Better”. Thus, over a period of time, when such members are in a majority in a lodge, the rituals might become mere formalities, the brotherhood will be contained to some leisure meetings where everyone meets once in a month, discuss charity, spare some money for it and vanish in their daily routines for another month, without any sense of purpose. It becomes more of a FELLOWSHIP CLUB. And if someone is looking forward to join a Fellowship Club, or Social Networking Club, I guess Freemasonry will appear quite boring and orthodox to him.

    In the end I would like to mention that I have been initiated very recently and have very limited exposure to the working of a Lodge. So, if any of above is out of context or inccorect interpretation, I would love to be corrected.

    Vaibhav Agarwal

  3. Hello gentle men ,
    I feel it very paramount important to express my feeling towards your highly respect organasition;Is that some time last two (2)months I Made an inqury as what are the moderlity or formality that one will be able to joing the organasition and if any i will be extremely glad to know, thank and God bless you all.

Comments are closed.