Georgia Black Mainstream Mason Is Black Balled Again For The Second Time In His Masonic Journey

Sometimes lightening strikes twice – to the same spot. When it does you know that either God is in control or the fix is in. In the case of Gate City Lodge #2, Atlanta, Georgia it is definitely the latter.

You might remember the articles The Beehive published in 2009 – My Brother’s Keeper, Open Racism in Georgia Freemasonry and Georgia: Not Such A Peachy Masonic State describing the machinations that the Grand Lodge of Georgia went through to try to keep out a Black African-American.  His name was Victor Marshall and he was raised to the sublime degree of Master Mason by Gate City Lodge #2, after which the Worshipful Master  was brought up on charges –  of “allowing a non-white man to join Freemasonry” –   that were approved by the Grand Master.

Georgia, blackball, Freemasonry

Since no Black Man had been initiated in Georgia Freemasonry in 275 years, the charges were interpreted that “Ancient Lights” of the Grand Lodge of Georgia prohibited Black Men from becoming F & AM.  The charges called for the Worshipful Master to be expelled and the Lodge to lose its Charter.   Mortified by this blatantly evil and certainly illegal affront to the Lodge, and having had first-hand experience with “Masonic Justice”, David Johnston and David Llewellyn, members of Gate City Lodge No. 2 and attorneys, filed for an injunction in civil court against the Grand Lodge of Georgia.

Oooppps – The Grand Lodge never thought the public would find that out.  When they did and the resulted outcry reached a clamor of disdain as the story spread throughout the nation, the plaintiffs in the case revoked their charges and the Grand Lodge of Georgia ultimately backed down deciding that was one battle they could not win.

They say by doing that one lives to fight another day. And that other day has arrived. Victor Marshall and Zeithlin Waters from Gate City Lodge #2, both Raised on the same night and having studied their catechisms together, submitted applications to the Atlanta Scottish Rite Body. Now the first thing that you have to understand about the story that will unfold here is that it is SOP to ballot on an entire class with one ballot for all. And so on November of 2010 the entire class of applications including Marshall and Waters was balloted upon. One or more black balls were cast on the first ballot.  Then and only then was an individual ballot cast for each applicant one at a time. Marshall and Waters were the last two to be voted on and both were blackballed. All others were approved. No comments were made on the ballot and the two Brothers were informed that their applications were not approved and that it would be six months before they could reapply.

In March of 2011 a called Communication of the Scottish Rite Valley of Atlanta was held for the purpose of balloting on a new class. This class did not include Marshall & Waters for they were still waiting out their 6 months to reapply. As was the custom the entire class was balloted upon with one ballot. On the first ballot one or more black balls were cast.  Each petition was then read individually and subsequently black balled. The whispered speculation was that Gate City Lodge members or sympathizers were striking back for the black balling of Marshall and Waters. The Personal Representative to the Grand Master rose to say how ashamed he was to be a Mason that night – thus commenting on a ballot which is actually unmasonic and a chargeable offense.

On April of 2011 at a stated meeting of the Scottish Rite Valley of Atlanta was held with business being among other things balloting on candidates once again. This vote was taken on a few new petitions as well as all of the candidates black balled in March. Again Marshall and Waters were not included. On the first ballot for the entire class one or more black balls were cast. The individual petitions were then read and balloted upon.  Each petition was rejected (black balled).

The SGIG arose to speak castigating any who would use the ballot for retribution and declaring how ashamed he was of the way this process had worked out. He went on to say that whoever threw the cubes was suffering from a mental illness.  He declared the ballot null and void and then took the unprecedented action of healing the ballot declaring all petitions granted.  He also ordered the black balls expunged from the personal records of those who received them. 

On October of 2011 a called Communication of The Scottish Rite Valley of Atlanta was held for the purpose of voting on petitions. For this called meeting a limited number of summonses had been sent out. Not everybody was called to this meeting.  This was a new class of 30 with Marshall and Waters added.  It had been almost a year since they had been black balled.  They could not get into the spring class of 2011 as not quite six months had lapsed since they had been black balled.  They had waited their 6 months and reapplied.   Before the vote, the SGIG advised all called to vote their conscience. But this time around the voting would not operate in the usual manner.  The entire class would not be balloted upon en masse as was the custom. Right from the start each candidate would be balloted upon individually, and Marshall and Waters were ballots number 29 and 30, the last two.  In the hour and a half that ensued, twenty eight candidates were approved but the 29th and 30th, Marshall and Waters, were blackballed. Once again the SGIG rose to thank all who participated for voting their conscience.  But he did not heal Marshall and Waters as he had done with the class of April 2011. He did not ask that the black balls be expunged from their Masonic records either.

This is where you can say the fix is in. The very actions of the leadership involved in this process leads to that conclusion. The SGIG and The Personal Representative to the Grand Master were only ashamed of any black balling when it did not involve Marshall and Waters. Comments were made by those in power after the balloting process in the 2nd and 3rd cases but not in the 1st and 4th when Marshall and Waters were being considered. The rules or the customary methods of procedure were changed at the leadership’s whim. The SGIG could heal an entire class but he couldn’t heal just two others.  He could heal a whole class in one month not making them wait 6 months to be voted on again but he wouldn’t extend that privilege to Marshall and Waters. In both instances where candidates were voted on individually Marshall and Waters were always the last two to be balloted upon.

Of further note, the crowd at the ballot box swelled when Waters and Marshall’s petitions were being voted upon.  Yet, during the two votes when entire classes were being cubed, there was an instance where a Grand Lodge of Georgia Officer stopped an entire line of voters from proceeding by refusing to move forward to cast his ballot.   At one point, only three people, other than Scottish Rite Officers, were voting.

Georgia Mainstream Freemasons think they have won the second battle, round two. But they thought the same way in the first round before the publicity forced them to retreat. Here we are again fighting the same fight and calling upon all Masons nationwide to put pressure upon The Scottish Rite, Southern Jurisdiction to act in a Masonic manner, put an end to such shenanigans and heal Marshall and Waters without further comment. If we did it once we can do it again.  The ball is in your court, Brother.

Posted in The Bee Hive and tagged , , , .

Fred is a Past Master of Plymouth Lodge, Plymouth Massachusetts, and Past Master of Paul Revere Lodge, Brockton, Massachusetts. Presently, he is a member of Pride of Mt. Pisgah No. 135, Prince Hall Texas, where is he is also a Prince Hall Knight Templar . Fred is a Fellow of the Phylaxis Society and Executive Director of the Phoenix Masonry website and museum.


  1. Change certainly can’t come if I follow Brother Beehive’s advice. He says on one hand that he wants GA to change, then tells me to demit and go to another jurisdiction to show my disdain. If I demit and walk away, and all those who want change demit and walk away, then it will never change. I may be a “new mason” but that doesn’t make me a fool. Nor will I suffer myself to be insulted or treated like one by a another….even if he is a brother. If the people of my mind demit, then nothing will EVER change. Of course that does make for more good “articles” to write.
    You say “Y’all aren’t going to recognize Prince Hall”, and that may be true in the immediacy..not my decision Beehive…I have no GL vote. Quitting insures that as well.

  2. they will tell you that you are not blackballed, but they won’t renew your membership card. The run around. If you demit or move to another jurisdiction it looks like you did something wrong when you didn’t.

    I was an officer in the blue and the scottish rite. When WM solicited me in lodge with a fishy sounding gasoline buying scheme involving his son in the midwest I didn’t appreciate it. I was raised AF*AM where this is not allowed,. However I was at an AF*M lodge in Yorba Linda, CA.

    I asked my superior officer if he had been solicited to as well. He said yes, and that he didn’t appreciate it either. Guess what? Neither one of us got our memberships renewed. I was given the runaround about my former lodge. Former lodge says they they don’t know anything about it. Bottome line, WM _______ thought I was going to write the GL and complain.

    I was the newest member, the lowest officer and felt intimidated by this solicitation. It was his first time as WM. I was the captain of the guard with the scottish rite in santa ana. I loved it. All gone now. My life is ruined. I love freemasonry and did nothing wrong.

    Cronies run it now. Mostly vets and english torries. the principles are still old, grand and good but greedy new WM’s can ruin a mans masonic career. In my case a very long, multi-generation career. I was told I was on my way to becomiing the youngest grandmaster in California and have a Grandmaster in my family history. two actually.

    YL469 is refractory. ________ should be blackballed, not me. May the sun never shine on YL469. Sincerely, solemnly. I remain and upright man.

    Orange County, CA

  3. Victor Marshall, a Master Mason and My Brother, is now Worshipful Master of Gate City Lodge No. 2 of Atlanta, a Regular Lodge of Free & Accepted Masons working under the Jurisdiction of the Grand Lodge of Georgia.

    There may still be racists but there is no bigotry in our Grand Lodge.

    ED Lamour, SW
    Mableton Lodge No. 171

  4. If this is truly racism, which it sounds like it is, it is an utter disgrace to the essence Freemasonry worldwide. Know that in other countries in the world this kind of racism does not exist. Wake up, it’s the 21st century or further obscure the Light of us all. Sad indeed that this exists.

  5. I really think this id a disgrace that this is oing,on in our entire order…we are all under the same umbrella,as brothers we need to start acting like it….S.M.I.B…/G\…

  6. Pingback: Recognition, History and the Masonic Path Less Traveled, an Interview with Fred Milliken | Freemason Information

Comments are closed.